Jane Ann McLachlan
  • Home
  • Book Accessories: Hand Crafted Bookmarks
  • HISTORICAL FICTION
  • Young Adult SF& F and Children's Books
  • CONNECTIONS: Parables for Today
  • Join The Conversation: My Blog, Your Response
  • Receive Free Stories
  • Check my Events Schedule and Contact Me

An Experiment in Publishing

1/3/2014

6 Comments

 
Happy New Year, 2014!
My personal challenge for 2014 (challenges are on-going; resolutions are temporary) is to learn whether an author can do better through self-publishing (s/p) or by being traditionally published (t/p).  So I'm conducting an experiment in publishing models. If you've ever wondered which route to take, t/p or s/p,follow my journey this year, and we'll find out together.

I intend to compare the two models on timing, personal satisfaction, and financial gain. I considered adding stress (= effort + frustration), but I think the stress (e+f) of finding an agent or publisher has been about equal, for me, to the stress of being responsible for everything.

I have done my best to make the odds equal, by maximizing the benefits each model has to offer, but of course there are huge variables and I am only a sample of one. That said, here are my methods:
cover of Science fiction novel Walls of Wind: Part I
Self-publishing Model
Part I of my Science Fiction novel, Walls of Wind, will go up today on Amazon as an e-book. Parts II and III will follow at monthly intervals. CreateSpace will offer POD copies for those who prefer print books, when the trilogy is completed. Halfway through the year, after I've taken advantage of Amazon's exclusivity marketing methods, I'll upload the trilogy to other online platforms: B & N, Apple, Kobo, etc. I'll also have 150 printed for my sales and promotion.
I had a professional editor do the line-editing and hired ExpertSubjects to provide professional covers for each e-book and convert the files into e-Pub and e-Mobi. These things would be handled by professionals in a traditional model, so I am equalizing the comparison.

Traditional Publishing Model
Award for my historical fiction novel The Sorrow Stone
In 2013 I attended three conferences. At the first, I pitched to agents and later signed with one at Prospect Agency; at the second, I pitched to publishers and secured 4 requests for my agent to send them my novel when it's ready; at the third I won first prize for my novel, The Sorrow Stone, in the unpublished historical fiction category. My agent has worked with me to get this novel and a memoir on offer.

Initial Results

Timing: It's taken over a decade to get an agent; it took two years to learn enough about s/p to decide to do it. To be fair, during that decade I was also improving my craft, which will equally benefit both methods. At this point, the starting line, I have 2 books on offer (t/p) and one book (s/p) going up as an ebook today. It is 3 days late (intended for Jan 1st); my last t/p book, CONNECTIONS, was 1 & 1/2 weeks late in printing.

Personal Satisfaction:  I love my agent, Carrie Pestritto, we work well together. William, Marija and Patrick at Expert Subjects have also all been great. At this point, it's pretty much equal.

Financial Gain: At this point it has all been losses. The conferences to pitch to agents and publishers were WAY more expensive than the price Expert Subjects is charging. However, the writing, marketing and s/p workshops at the conferences, and the friends I made (also good contacts, but I think of them as friends), will equally benefit both models. I think I'll call it a draw.

Despite the many variables, there are enough similarities to make this, for me, a viable experiment. Same author, same quality of writing, same professional product in cover, editing & formatting.  I look forward to seeing who wins, and will keep you updated as I go along.

Meanwhile, what are your thoughts or experiences with these two models of publishing?
6 Comments

    RSS Feed

    Picture
    Join my readers' community and receive two complete short stories  & a free copy of  Walls of Wind: Part I.

    Get YOUR free stories
    30 DAYS TO PREPARE  YOUR NOVEL!
    Read my posts on preparing to write your next novel each day during October 2015

    30 DAYS OF MARKETING TIPS!

    Read my  posts on Marketing your books or e-books - 1 post  every day of September 2014, beginning HERE.

    Archives

    June 2019
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    March 2016
    October 2015
    September 2015
    May 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012

    Categories

    All
    October Breakout Novel Challenge
    October Memoir & Backstory Blog Challenge 2012
    Publishing Experiment
    September Book & EBook Marketing Challenge
    Weekly Memoir Promp

    Memoir & Backstory Blog Challenge 2013
    Participants:
    (Read about the 2013 Challenge  - click here)

    Jane Ann McLachlan
    Joy Weese Moll @joyweesemoll
    Amanda M Darling
    Katie Argyle
    PK Hrezo
    Claudette Young
    Kay Kauffman
    Leslie
    Deb Stone    Twitter: @iwritedeb
    Gerry Wilson
    Susan Hawthorne
    Satia Renee
    Bonnie
    Angie
    Pearl Ketover Prilik
    Terri Rowe
    Pamela Mason
    Rebecca Barray
    Lara Britt 
    Linda G Hatton
    Stephanie Ingram
    Anastacia, Stacey Rene, Talynn
    Memoir & Backstory Blog Challenge 2012
    Participants:

    Learn about the October Blog Challenge 2012 here.

    Jane Ann McLachlan
    Swagger Writers
    Charli Armstrong
    Alexandra Campbell
    Susan Tilghman Hawthorn
    T.J.
    Lara Britt
    Dr. Margaret Aranda
    Kristina Perez
    Stephanie Ingram
    Richard P. Hughes 
    Meghan
    Joy Weese Moll
    Neil
    Kay
    Gerry Wilson
    Veronica Roth
    Mrs. Darcy
    Morgan Katz 
    Anthony Dutson
    Jessica Becker
    Anna Priemaza
    Todd R. Moody
    Jessica Lerma
    Satia Renee
    Benita Bowen